Submit your papersSubmit Now
For Enquiries: [email protected]
IIARD LogoIIARD

Intelligence Governance and the Dynamics of Insecurity in Fragile Democracies: A Comparative Study of Nigeria, Burkina Faso, and Mali

Abubakar Sanusi Imam, ---, Alfa Abdulhamid Muhammad

Abstract

The research investigates intelligence governance practices in three nations Nigeria, Burkina Faso, and Mali which each experience insecure conditions because of insurgents and bandits and jihadist organizations. The study uses secondary data to conduct a comparative analysis which examines how intelligence systems operate through three different security force development stages and their impact on state institutions and security services. The research applies Security Governance Theory Democratic Oversight Theory and State Fragility Theory to show which elements shape intelligence operations through state and non-state actors, ineffective oversight systems, and governance deficits. Intelligence agencies across all three nations experience operational difficulties because of disjointed operations, political meddling, insufficient monitoring, geographical restrictions, and high levels of public distrust. Community defence groups and militias and vigilantes’ function as hybrid security forces which deliver site-specific intelligence while undermining government control and making national intelligence operations more difficult. The study demonstrates that the intelligence systems of these nations operate under two major deficiencies which result in their current danger situation. The study recommends several actions which include improving intelligence operations through better coordination and advanced democratic monitoring and hybrid actor regulation and community trust development and institutional changes through extended periods. The establishment of intelligence governance systems which focus on accountable practices and collaborative efforts will create better national defense systems and bring back public trust in unstable democratic systems.

References

Abrahamsen, R., & Williams, M. (2011). Security beyond the state: Private security in international politics. Cambridge University Press. Adeleke, A. (2020). State fragility and governance challenges in West Africa. African Security Review, 29(2), 115–130. Aiyede, E. (2019). Democratic control of security agencies in Nigeria. Journal of Security Studies, 12(1), 44–63. Bagayoko, N., Hutchful, E., & Luckham, R. (2016). Hybrid security governance in Africa: Principles, pitfalls and perspectives. Global Security: Health, Science and Policy, 1(1), 1–10. Born, H., & Caparini, M. (2007). Democratic control of intelligence services: Containing rogue elephants. Ashgate. Born, H., & Leigh, I. (2005). Making intelligence accountable: Legal standards and best practice for oversight. Geneva Centre for the Democratic Control of Armed Forces. Bruneau, T. C., & Dombroski, K. R. (2014). Reforming intelligence: Lessons from abroad. University of Texas Press. Bruneau, T. C., & Matei, F. C. (2014). Intelligence reform in new democracies. Intelligence and National Security, 29(2), 149–170. Call, C. (2011). Beyond the ‘failed state’: Toward conceptual alternatives. European Journal of International Relations, 17(2), 303–326. Center for Strategic and International Studies . (2022). The Sahel crisis: Drivers, dynamics, and responses. CSIS Africa Program Report. Debos, M. (2016). Living by the gun in Chad: Combatants, impunity and state formation. Zed Books. Gill, P. (2016). Intelligence governance and democratization: A comparative analysis of oversight mechanisms. Routledge. Heni, K. (2022). Community militias and intelligence failures in Burkina Faso. Sahel Security Review, 8(3), 30–44. Higazi, A. (2018). Social dynamics of security in Nigeria’s northeast. African Affairs, 117(468), 617–640. International Crisis Group. (2021). Violence in Nigeria: The dangerous expansion of armed groups. ICG Africa Report. International Crisis Group. (2022). Burkina Faso: Stopping the spiral of violence. ICG Africa Report. Kaboré, M. (2021). Community mistrust and state security failure in Burkina Faso. Journal of Modern African Studies, 59(1), 89–110. Krahmann, E. (2003). Conceptualizing security governance. Cooperation and Conflict, 38(1), 5–26. Onuoha, F. (2020). Intelligence failures and Boko Haram’s growth. Studies in Conflict & Terrorism, 43(4), 268–290. Rotberg, R. (2004). When states fail: Causes and consequences. Princeton University Press. Tyler, T. (2006). Why people obey the law. Princeton University Press. United Nations Development Programme . (2023). Journey to extremism in Africa: Pathways to recruitment. Wing, S. (2018). Community security, state weaknesses, and intelligence gaps in Mali. African Security, 11(2), 72–91. Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development . (2005). Security system reform and governance. OECD Publishing.

More Articles from INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SOCIAL SCIENCES AND MANAGEMENT RESEARCH