Adoption, Utilization and Challenges of Digital Health Technologies for Monitoring and Evaluation of Primary Health Care Programs in Rivers State, Nigeria
Abstract
Background: Digital health technologies are increasingly integrated into primary health care systems to strengthen routine data collection, reporting, programme monitoring and evidence-informed decision-making. Effective implementation depends on health-personnel adoption, routine utilization, supportive infrastructure and organisational capacity. In Nigeria, evidence on their adoption and use for monitoring and evaluation (M&E) at Primary health care level remains limited, particularly in Rivers State. Methods: A cross-sectional study was conducted among 602 primary health care personnel involved in health-data collection, reporting, supervision and programme monitoring. Participants were recruited through multistage sampling, and data were collected using a structured questionnaire developed from the study objectives. Descriptive statistics, Spearman’s rank-order correlation, group-comparison tests, Chi-square tests and multivariable regression were used; significance was set at p<0.05 Results: DHIS2 was most commonly used (84.7%), followed by NHLMIS (73.1%), electronic data-capture/reporting tools (65.8%), ODK (62.1%), NDARS (59.5%) and OpenMRS (42.0%). Mean adoption breadth was 4.34±1.25 technology categories; 75.6% used at least four categories. Routine utilization was extensive, averaging 8.95±1.10 of 10 monitoring and evaluation activities, while 38.4% reported frequent or very frequent digital use across all ten activities. Perceived monitoring and evaluation contribution was high (mean=3.61), with 99.2% positive endorsement. However, implementation challenges remained evident (mean=3.09). Adoption breadth was not significantly associated with perceived monitoring and evaluation contribution (ρ=−0.006, p=0.882), and UTAUT-related factors did not significantly predict adoption or continued use (R2=0.008; F (4,597) =1.150; p=0.332) Conclusion: Digital health technologies are widely adopted and routinely used for primary health care monitoring and evaluation in Rivers State and are perceived to contribute substantially to routine information processes. However, greater adoption alone did not improve perceived M&E contribution, and technology-acceptance factors did not independently explain utilization. Recommendation: Strengthening interoperability, infrastructure, workforce development, technical support, sustainable financing and institutional ownership is essential for resilient, scalable and effective primary health care monitoring and evaluation systems.
Keywords
References
More Articles from INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MEDICAL EVALUATION AND PHYSICAL REPORT
Author: Aaron Umasoye Udogadi, Agwu Michael Ezenna, and Stella Okwelle PC,
Author: Aaron Umasoye Udogadi,, Agwu, Michael Ezenna,, Ayodele Martins B. O., John, Elizabeth Ovuru, Olugbenga Bamigbowu, and Aniekan Affiah
Author: Tamunoboma Gloria Ibulubo, Anthony Ike Wegbom, Clement Kevin Edet., Priscillia, Nyekpunwo Ogbonda,, Corresponding author
Author: Kanu Micheal Iheanyichukwu1 David Vanessa Chinye 2 Mejeh Lucy Obiamaraije3
Author: Prof. Anthony I. Wegbom, Isaac Harold PhD, Kel-Kaizer Tam Queen
