Submit your papersSubmit Now
For Enquiries: [email protected]
IIARD LogoIIARD

Politics and the Independence of the Judiciary in Nigeria: The Appointment and Removal Procedure for Head of Courts

Kingsley Lemeah Peekate & Nuleera Ambrose Duson

Abstract

An independent judiciary is one of the corner stone for democracy to thrive in the society. It is an essential factor for constitutional democracy and the rule of law. Judicial independence means the ability of judges to function independently from outside influences that may corrupt or curtail their ability to fairly administer justice. It also means the independence of judges to think freely and act freely according to the dictates of their conscience in line with the provision of the law without any let or hindrance or fear of repercussion from any quarters. This article identified four factors which ensured judicial independence to include security of tenure/ remuneration, the implementation of due process in the appointment of judicial officers, due process in the removal of judicial officers, and obedience of court orders/ compliance thereto by executive and legislative bodies. The article examined events in Nigeria’s recent democratic history wherein heads of courts were unlawfully removed, appointed or elevated; appraised the removal procedure for head of courts; and exposed the motivation for tampering with judicial independence by politicians. The article maintained that without willing collaborators within the judiciary and the justice sector it would have been difficult to curtail judicial independence. The events surrounding disputes at the election tribunals, and appointment/ removal of head of courts showcased that Nigeria politicians in power have by all means pocket the judiciary and curtailed her independence. The politicians neglected the constitutional provisions in the appointment and removal of heads of courts, and appointed judicial officers willing to aid their political ambition/career. This scheme was majorly engendered to manoeuvre election disputes at the tribunal in favour of the politicians in power. This article suggested that excluding politicians from the appointment process of heads of courts

Keywords

PoliticsIndependenceJudiciaryAppointmentRemoval

References

P. O. Olatunbosun, History of West Africa (Ilesha: Fatiregun press & publishing company 1979) 285. P. A. O. Oluyede, Peter Oluyede's Constitutional Law in Nigeria (Ibadan: Evans- Brothers Ltd 1992) 74-75. Justice Salami vs CJN Saga: NJC Quashes Salami's Promotion, Vanguard Online News (10 Feb 2011) https://www.vanguardngr.com accessed 22 August 2023 Rivers Govt talks tough, says NJC lacks power to suspend Chief Judge Agumagu, Premium Times Online News https://www.premuimtimesng.com accessed 24 July 2023 P. O. Ogun, 'An Analysis of the Rule of Law during Constitutional Democracy in Nigeria' [Nov. 2021] (8) (2) Port Harcourt Journal of Business Law; 323-324. C. A. Odinkalu, 'Judicial Independence 62 years after Nigeria's Independence' Premium Times Online News (2 Oct 2022) https://www.premiumtimesng.com accessed 22 August 2023 I. Gwunireama, 'The Executive and Independence of the Judiciary in Nigeria' [Nov. 2022] (2) (1) PINISI Journal of Art, Humanity and Social Studies; 59. (n7) 60 (n2) 286 CFRN 1999 as amended, s. 84 (1)-(4), (7). CFRN 1999 as amended, Ss. 231 (1) (2), 238(1), 250(1), 254B (1), 256(1), 261(1), 266(1). Ibid, Ss. 238(2), 250(2), 2548 (2), 256(2), 261(2), 266(2) Ibid, Ss. 271(1), 276(1), 281(1) Ibid, Ss. 271(2), 276(2), 281(2) CFRN 1999 as amended, s. 292 Ibid, s. 292 (1) (a) (i) Ibid, s. 292 (1) (a) (ii) (n15) s. 292 (1) (b) (n1) 287; O. Balogun, The Tragic Years: Nigeria in Crises 1966-1970 (Benin City: Ethiope publishing corporation 1980) 2; S. Oyeweso, Perspective on the Nigerian Civil War (Lagos: OAP publications 1992) 126. J. M. Jaja & N. Aba-Erondu, Fundamentals of Government and Political Science (Port Harcourt: Pearl Publishers 2000) 16. D. Gberevbie and others, 'Corruption and Cost of Governance in Nigeria' in A. S. Akpotor and others (ed), Cost of Governance in Nigeria: An Evaluative Analysis (Ekpoma: Ambrose Alli University 2007) 401. Femi Adesina, 'How Obasanjo's Do-or-die Comments Caused Tension in 2007 21st Century Chronicle Roundtable (24 Feb 2022) https://21stcenturychronicle.com accessed 24 July 2023 (n20) 14 (n6) (n2) 287 A. S. Hornby, M. Ashby & S. Wehmeier, Oxford Advance Learner's Dictionary of Current English (6th edn, England: Oxford University Press 2000) 977 Mohammed Shosanya, 'Mixed Reactions Trail NJC's Suspension of Rivers CJ Daily Trust Online News (Lagos, 1 April 2014) https://dailytrust.com accessed 24 July 2023 CFRN 1999 as amended, s. 271(1) (2012) 13 NWLR (pt. 1318) 423; (2012) 40 WRN 1; (2012) LPELR SC.281/2010 (n4) Rivers Lawmakers Beat Up One Another With Assembly Mace' Premium Times Nigeria Online News (9 July 2013) https://www.premiumtimesng.com accessed 28 August 2023 CFRN 1999 as amended, s. 188(5) (n3) CFRN 1999 as amended, section 292(1) (a) (i) PDP v. INEC (1999) 11 NWLR (pt.626) 200; Ogbuniya v. Okudo (1976) 6-9 SC 32 (n2) 297 A. A. Olatunji SAN, 'Securing Independence of the Judiciary: The Way Forward' The Guardian Online News (27 Sept 2022) https://guardian.ng accessed 22 August 2023. CFRN 1999, s. 287

More Articles from JOURNAL OF LAW AND GLOBAL POLICY

A Critical Appraisal of Employment Contracts Under the Nigerian Law: Rights, Obligations, Termination, and Remedies

Author: Somotun, Olufemi Olalekan, PhD, Nwobodo, Nnamdi Joseph, Esq, Avoseh, Francis, Pedepo, Elijah, Udeme Dapo, Udofia, Kenneth Thompson, Okon, Imoh Essien, Mhambe Celestine Tersoo

State Responses to Hybrid Threats in Nigeria: A Critical Analysis of Terrorism, Banditry and Separatist Agitations, 2010-2025

Author: Adebimpe Saheed Fagbemi, Ph.D., Muhammad Sani Idris Doctoral Candidate, Mudassir Nasir, Ph.D.