Submit your papersSubmit Now
For Enquiries: [email protected]
IIARD LogoIIARD
📄 Download Paper

Comparative Analysis of Construction Project Outcomes: Supervised Vs. Unsupervised Execution

Chukwuebuka Emmanuel Okeke, Chijioke Steven Umeokana

Abstract

This study presents a comparative analysis of construction project outcomes under supervised and unsupervised execution in Anambra State, Nigeria. Using a quantitative and qualitative research approach, data were collected from 194 fully registered construction professionals to evaluate key performance indicators such as project quality, cost efficiency, time management, and safety compliance. The findings reveal that supervised projects consistently outperform unsupervised ones, with higher adherence to engineering standards, better budget discipline, timely completion, and improved safety compliance. In contrast, unsupervised projects exhibited substandard workmanship, frequent cost overruns, delays, and increased safety violations. The study underscores the importance of supervision in ensuring successful project execution and recommends mandatory supervision policies, stronger regulatory frameworks, professional training programs, and digital monitoring technologies to enhance construction outcomes in Nigeria. These findings contribute to the growing discourse on construction project management and the need for stricter oversight in the Nigerian building industry.

Keywords

Comparative AnalysisConstruction ProjectProject OutcomesSupervised ExecutionUnsupervised ExecutionProject ManagementQuality ControlCost Efficiency and Time Management.

References

Abdullahi, H. A., Yusuf, M. A., and Mohammed, B. S. (2020). The effects of project supervision on construction performance: A case study of public sector projects. Journal of Construction Management, 12(3), 45-59. Abubakar, S., and Mensah, T. (2020). Regulatory compliance and its impact on construction project outcomes in Africa. African Journal of Construction and Urban Studies, 15(2), 88- Adamu, M. (2021). Comparative research in construction project management: Methods and applications. Journal of Construction Studies in Africa, 12(3), 56-74. Adegboyega, O. (2019). Supervision and its impact on construction quality in Nigeria. Journal of Construction Management, 14(2), 112-127. Adekunle, R. (2022). Factors affecting project delays and cost overruns in Nigerian construction industry. Journal of African Infrastructure Development, 9(1), 45-63. Akinyemi, A. O., and Adewale, A. B. (2019). Challenges of unsupervised construction projects in developing countries. International Journal of Civil Engineering Research, 17(4), 102-118. Alwi, S., Hampson, K., and Mohamed, S. (2021). The impact of supervision on construction productivity: A systematic review. Construction Economics and Building, 21(2), 78-94. Chukwudi, I., and Bello, A. (2022). Systems theory in construction project management: Insights from Nigerian projects. Nigerian Journal of Building Research, 8(1), 54-70. Eze, J., and Adebayo, K. (2021). Building collapse and the implications of poor supervision in Nigeria. West African Journal of Civil Engineering, 14(3), 112-129. Ezeokoli, O. and Okongwu, I. 2020 – Adaptability of COVID-19 Safety Guidelines in Building Construction Sites in Anambra State, Nigeria Ibrahim, A. (2021). Challenges of unsupervised construction execution in Nigeria: An empirical investigation. Journal of Civil Engineering in Nigeria, 17(3), 203-219. Musa, O. (2020). Workmanship and material quality in unsupervised construction projects: An assessment of risks and challenges. Journal of Building Technology and Management, 11(4), 56-72. Nwachukwu, C., and Okorie, B. (2019). Cost management in construction: The role of supervision and accountability. Nigerian Journal of Project Economics, 7(2), 75-91. Ojo, S. (2021). The significance of supervision in achieving construction project success in Nigeria. Construction Economics Review, 19(1), 35-50. Okafor, L. (2020). Risk management and the role of supervision in Nigerian construction projects. Nigerian Journal of Infrastructure Studies, 12(4), 89-105. Oke, A. E., Ogunsemi, D. R., and Amusan, L. M. (2020). Project supervision and its impact on the quality of construction projects. Journal of Built Environment Research, 15(1), 33-49. Okonkwo, P., and Eze, J. (2020). Challenges of construction project execution in Anambra State, Nigeria. Nigerian Journal of Infrastructure and Development, 8(2), 103-118. Oladipo, T. (2021). Occupational health and safety compliance in African construction sites: The case for effective supervision. International Journal of Safety and Risk Management, 16(1), 23-39. Oyedele, O. A., and Thwala, W. D. (2022). The role of supervision in mitigating construction risks: A comparative approach. International Journal of Project Management, 30(1), 27-42. Uchenna, C. (2021). Reliability testing in construction research: An application of Cronbach’s alpha coefficient. African Journal of Construction and Engineering Research, 14(1), 67-82.

More Articles from INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ENGINEERING AND MODERN TECHNOLOGY

Structural Design of a High-Rise Structure Using Protostructure Software

Author: Oluwole A. Olaniyi, Afeez K. Oyelami, Taiwo T. Adebayo, Oluwagbenga D., Adegbola

Determination of the Physical Properties of Local Surfactants for Enhancing Oil Recovery

Author: Bowei, Dauseighe Matthew

Bridging the Scale Gap in Dryland Carbon Accounting: A Multi- Scalar Hybrid Methodology and the Composite Ecosystem Stability Index (CESI) for the Sudan Savanna

Author: Abdulrahman Aminu, Muhammed Mustapha, Muhammad Abubakar Gusau, Musa, Muhammad Anka, Al-Mustapha Faisal

Comparative Analysis of Solar Energy Potential in Urban and Rural Areas of Nasarawa State

Author: Yahaya Seidu Oteke

The Role of Nigeria’s Petroleum Industry Act (PIA) of 2021 in Addressing the Energy Trilemma of Security, Sustainability, and Affordability

Author: Anochie Lydia Onyinye