IIARD International Institute of Academic Research and Development

International Journal of Engineering and Modern Technology (IJEMT )

E-ISSN 2504-8848
P-ISSN 2695-2149
VOL. 8 NO. 4 2022
DOI: https://doi.org/10.56201/ijemt.v8.no4.2022.pg74.85

---

Dissonances in Building Cost: An Analytic Review of the Impact of Design Variables

Mac-Barango, D. O.

---

Abstract

The cost of building is influenced by a variety of design variables. There would however appear a paucity of readily available cost data on the impact of design variables. This research is set out with a view towards the establishing readily available cost data information as well as relevant cost indices. The research used case study from previous buildings, extensive reviews, the statistical technique of percentile as its computational technique and rates obtained from synthesized bills priced by professional Quantity Surveying firms, as relevant components of its methodology. The location of the research, Port Harcourt metropolis is situated in Niger Delta region of Nigeria. Research findings from the case study buildings as well as extensive literature review established that there exist differentials in the initial and total costs of both building plan Shapes (Square and rectangular), recording a 12.56 percentage differential. The elemental cost derived from both shapes also established differentials between 0.53 to 17.79%. The study also establishes the perimeter wall and gross floor area ratio which is an important index towards the determination of economic building shapes. The research concludes that the results, from the case study building would appear limited and as such should avoid being overgeneralized, nevertheless, it does serves to further reveal in broad terms, that the influence of plan shapes of simple buildings on cost is minimal. It recommends further, exploratory study that focuses on design and their cost implications, using cost models that input a wider range of variables.

keywords:

Construction industry, design, plan shape, other design variables, size of building cost implications of design variables

---

References:

Allsop, K. (2015): “Buildability”: An Architects View Architect Journal, Vol. 177 4:29

Al-Zahrani A. (2005): “Cost Implications of Architectural Design Variables, Unpublished. 2005.

Ainomugisha et al (2015): Cost Implications of Building Design Plan: A Literature Review
Analysis by ICETEA 2015 ISSN 2470-4330.

Aribisala, O. (1990): Inputs of Local Materials in Buildings as a means of reducing cost of
construction. The Nigerian Quantity Surveyors 10:4. Journal of the Nigerian Institute of
Quantity Surveyors, Lagos.

Ashworth, (1988): Cost Studies of Buildings. Longman Scientific and Technical UK. Pp 53 and
115.

Ashworth, R. M. and Skitmore (1983): “Accuracy in Estimating” Chartered Institute of
Building.
Ashworth, A. H. and Willis, Practice and Procedure Quantity Surveyors Blackwell Science Ltd,
2004.

Bathurst, P. E. and Butler, D. A. (1980): Building Cost Control Techniques and Economics
Second Edition. Heineman. London.

Beetson D. T. (1987): “A Future for Cost Modeling and Computers”. E. F. N. Spon pp. 15-24.
Berg, D. Fisher, S and Dornbush, R. (1991): Economics third edition. Me Graw-Hill Book
Company - London New York, San Francisco.

Cartlidge, D. P. (1976): Construction Design Economics. Hutchinson, London.

Chau, K. W. (1999): On the issue of plan shape complexity: Plan shape indices revisited.
Construction Management Economics. P. 17.

Chau, Y. Y. and Wong (2007): “Determining optimal building height”, Urban Stud. Vol. 44, no
33, pp. 591-607.

Charleson A. W. (2005): Structure and Architecture. Oxford Architectural Press.

Crayon (2003): Graphisoft?s Virtual Building Concept (2003) Available Online.
http:www.wbh.com/whitepapers/Graphicsoft-virtual building model – a crayon Research
White Paper.

Cunningham T., (2013): “Factors Affecting the Cost of Building Work. An Overview. Dublin
Institute of Technology: 2013

Ferry and Brandon, P. (1991): Cost Planning of Buildings Granada Publishers.

Ferick H. (1998): “Sistem Bentuk Struktur Banigunan: Dasar-dasar konstruksi dalam Arsitektur”
Yogyakarta Kanisius. 1998.

Gray, W. H. C. (2001): Building Design Management: Butter worth-Heineman Boston.

Gray C. (1982): Analysis of the Preliminary Element of Building Production Costs In Brandon
P. S. (ed): Building Cost Techniques New Directions E. F. Span Ltd. London, New
York.

Ibrahim, D. A. (2003): Effect of changes in Building Layout on the unit construction cost of
Residential Building. Unpublished Text. Quantity Surveying Section, Department of
Surveying. Faculty of Engineering. Ahmadu Bello University Zaria, Nigeria.

Ibrahim, D. A. (2003): Establishing Relationship between building size and unit Construction
Cost of Residential building. Unpublished text. Quantity Surveying Section. Department
of Surveying. Ahmadu Bellow University, Zaria, Nigeria. P 6 and 8.

Ibrahim A. et al (2015): Assessment of the Effect of Plan Shapes on Cost of Institutional
Buildings in Nigeria. International Journal of Science and Engineering volume 4 no.
Issue 3 pp. 39-50.

Ibrahim A. D. (2007): “Effect of changes in Building Layout on unit construction cost of
Residential Building,” Quant Surv. Sect. 2007.
Kouskoulas, V and Koehin, E (1974): Pre-design Cost estimation function for building. Journal
of construction division, ASCE 100:12:589- 604.

Marton and Jagger (1995): Design and the Economics of Building Spoon Press.

Nordberg, R (2000): Building Sustainable Cities. Habitat Debate Vol. 5 No. 2.

Pena S. A. and Apr W. Shell (2001): Problem Seeking: An Architectural Programming Primer
4 th Edition. New York Willey 2001.

Sakifi et al (2015): Cost Implications for Building Design Plans: A Literature Review Analysis:
Accessed online via

Seeley, I. H. (1976): Building Maintenance. Macmillan publishers limited. Basingstoke and
London.

Seeley, I. H. (1983): Building Economics. Macmillan Publishers. London.

Seeley, I. H. (1996): Building Economics. Macmillan Publishers. London.

Seeley, I. H. (1997): Building Economics: 5 th Edition. The Macmillan Press Ltd.
London.

Shash, A. A. and Ibrahim, D. A. (2005): Surveys of Procedures adopted by Architectural-
Engineering Firms in Accounting for Design Variables in Early cost Estimates. J. King
Saud University, Engineering Science 18:1:2.

Shash, A. A. and Ibrahim, D. A. (2005): Surveys of Procedures adopted by Architectural -
Engineering Firms in Accounting for Design Variables in Early cost Estimates. J. King
Saud University, Engineering Science 18:1:2. P.4.

Shutt, R. C. (1988): Economics for the Construction Industry. Second Edition. Longman
Scientific and Technical England. Pp 229 and 231.

Swaffield, L. M. and Pasquire, C. L. (1995): A Critical Analysis of Building
Services Cost
Prediction Models. In: Proceedings of the eleventh ARCOM Annual Conference.

Swaffeld, L. M. and Pasquire, C. L. (1999): Examination of Relationships between Building
Forms and Functions and the Cost of Mechanical and Electrical Services. Construction
Management Economics 17.

Swaffield, C. I. and Pasquire L. M.” A Critique of Mechanical and Electrical Services Cost
Planning: existing methods and published information. Journal of Financial Management
Property Construction Vol. 1, no 3 pp. 23-41

DOWNLOAD PDF

---

Back